TromboneChat

Anyone have any info on silver Bach 42s? Theres one listed on ebay for a pretty good price, but I haven’t seen any info on a silver plated version of a Bach 42 so I figured I’d ask to get more info before I make a decision.

Not much to say, usually they are former military or marching instruments. Rare option for a "normal" person, though obviously some are out there.

Silver plate has been a standard option on all Bach models for decades. The instrument is not made any differently to a lacquered one, other than being plated, instead of being lacquered.

I attended a summer academy ten years ago as a student conductor, and ended up being asked to play as well in some of the orchestra concerts because of a last minute trombonist cancellation. I hadn't brought my horn and the festival borrowed an instrument from the host college. It was a silver plated 42C, and it's in my top 3 of all the 42s I've ever tried. It was an absolute joy to get to play that horn for 3 weeks. Don't know how much of it was the silver plate and how much just that it was a fine specimen, but it had a freer blow than the average 42 and a really complex and lively sound with not even a hint of dullness.

Just as there are Lacquered Bach Trumpets, there are Silvered Bach trombones. You just see them less often around the U.S. currently.

I have a sliver-plated 42BO. It plays tighter and brighter than my lacquer 42BO. Both built in the 1980's, I attribute it mostly to production variances. I do prefer the silver version for me as the lacquer version is more open and darker.

Your mileage may vary.

Carl

Played a bunch of Silber plated Bachs as it is what my employer asks for from time to time. Did not like a single one of them. Nut sure if it is because of the plating or if these were just bad Bachs but I feel like all the cool things about Bach were not happening with these Silber plated horns. Would not recommend.

Just so people know that there is a flip side of the coin……

When I was in my early 20’s, a buddy of mine had a silver-plated Bach 42B. That horn was absolutely phenomenal. I remember that everything felt effortless on it, and it felt very secure in all registers. It was a “Corporation” horn, probably made in the late 1970s.

Of course, the silver plating probably had nothing to do with its playability. It was just a great horn!

Found a silver 42 (no letters), pretty open wrap design, no case () at a pawn shop. Decent shape, playable (I’m relearning now). I wanted a silver horn & a Bach through high school but never obtained. To find one as an adult for $400, I could hardly contain my excitement! I’m enjoying playing again more than I expected. Now to find a TR180 at a great price…

My former school has a 42C (removable valve). It has cup-and-socket valve linkage. I used it for quite a while.

I have a silver Selmer by Bach with an F attachment…looks like a 42…Unsure of the age but it’s a jewel to play. Has anyone else see one like this? I bought it over 25 years ago and it was a used purchase from a local dealer.

Timwithabone wrote: ↑Fri Jun 07, 2024 8:13 pm I have a silver Selmer by Bach with an F attachment…looks like a 42…Unsure of the age but it’s a jewel to play. Has anyone else see one like this? I bought it over 25 years ago and it was a used purchase from a local dealer.

It's not by Bach. Most likely a Selmer Largo. Fine instrument; made in France for the European market.

The best 42 I ever owned was a silver plated early Elkhart. Absolutely fabulous horn. Then I got into Manhattan School of Music and everyone was giving me the side eye for having a silver plated horn, (or so I thought) so I had the plating removed. That ruined the horn.
The bottom line is: if it sounds good and plays good, it is good, don’t hear with your eyes.

pipperz wrote: ↑Sun Mar 31, 2024 8:01 pm Anyone have any info on silver Bach 42s? Theres one listed on ebay for a pretty good price, but I haven’t seen any info on a silver plated version of a Bach 42 so I figured I’d ask to get more info before I make a decision.

I'm sure you've checked, but is it a silver-plated 42, or a 42 with a "Sterling Plus" silver bell, which were briefly fashionable in the 1990s? Very different; lovely sound, and if nothing else, more valuable (being made from solid Sterling silver).