Edwards/ Getzen 2nd Valve Comfort

[GBP]

I have never liked how Edwards/Getzen have set up the second valve lever. I like how Greenhoe and Edwards 502i have the 2nd valve lever positioned. I think it could be the design in combination with the paddle. I should probably take it to a tech and see what they can do, but figured I can’t be the only one who has found the setup somewhat uncomfortable. What have some of you done to improve the position of the lever?

[BurckhardtS]

To be completely honest, I have not found a single bass trombone 2 valve setup that I have ever found comfortable. I almost have to play with a brace on to feel even remotely comfortable playing two valves.

[TheBoneRanger]

Seems like you answered your own question. Take it to a tech.

Andrew

[ghmerrill]

I continue to be astonished that so many people try to adapt their bodies to the instrument rather than to adapt the instrument to their bodies -- particularly in the cases of things like better hand support or lever position where minor modifications can make such a big difference in playing comfort and performance. Maybe people are afraid to change the "stock horn" in case they want to sell it at some point, and so endure years discomfort and degraded playing?

Of course, it may take some time and experimentation to get it just right instead of an attempt at a one-time fix.

[whitbey]

This is wild. I have large hands and add a brace to the slide. Like a Rube Goldberg project. But is works well for me. I did it before many second valves were as they are now. Images are in my profile.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B1izx3 ... VrZ0k/view

[ghmerrill]

I have relatively small hands. For me the biggest changes were removing the finger ring under the mouthpiece receiver and putting a finger hook (actually intended for a French horn) on the other (forward) side of the brace. Then altering the second valve lever so I could adjust it and lengthen/shorten it without bending the whole lever itself. Turned a painful experience into a very pleasant and playable horn with great balance in the hand. Also a bullet brace, of course.

[GBP]

Seems like you answered your own question. Take it to a tech.

Andrew

My question was what have others had done to their horns to improve comfort, not who did the work.

[Backbone]

Are you asking specifically what people have done to the Edwards/Getzen setup? Or any split trigger setup?

[TheBoneRanger]

Seems like you answered your own question. Take it to a tech.

Andrew

My question was what have others had done to their horns to improve comfort, not who did the work.

Ok then. This time I shall be explicit.

With my Edwards, after deciding I didn't really like the 2nd valve lever geometry, I thought to myself...

I should probably take it to a tech and see what they can do

...so I took it to my tech to see what he could do.

Upon his advice, we applied a little heat to bend a lever, and came up with a custom paddle for the 2nd valve.

Andrew

[GBP]

Are you asking specifically what people have done to the Edwards/Getzen setup? Or any split trigger setup?

Any setup similar would be helpful. Thanks.

[mrdeacon]

Take it a tech. Have it bent or cut. The stock setup is garbage like on a stock Bach 50B3.

I had like a full 2-3 inches (if I remember right) cut on the second valve lever on my 1062FDR. It was unusable for me before I got it cut.

The old stock Gb paddle looks funky at first but I find it to be one of the most comfortable paddles out there. You can change the angle of it, flip it around backward or move it pretty drastically up and down the lever rod to find a comfortable spot for it.

[ghmerrill]

I don't really understand why virtually all of the stock paddles for 2nd valves are so large. I THINK it's an attempt to provide a larger "one size fits all" area that's more usable by more players, but it's a dreadful solution to that. To my mind, you want a smaller paddle (or none at all, and rather just the rod end, possibly flattened). And about 2" is what I cut off the rod on my 7B clone -- and sleeved a shorter rod on it with the paddle (a coin) soft-soldered to it. A paddle that's almost the size of a quarter is really silly.

[pompatus]

I recently had my 50B2 rebuilt with the Instrument Innovations axial valves, and it's now very similar to the Edwards B454-V-E configuration they currently have listed. My tech used the Instrument Innovations adjustable F lever for the first valve linkage, which has a built in mounting point for the Ax Handle brace rods. I've used an Ax Handle/Bullet Brace type support for years, which has helped a lot.

In addition to the Ax Handle, with this "new" horn I switched to a different left hand grip, like what Douglas Yeo has documented on his website, and those two things have made an enormous difference in left hand/wrist comfort. I'll include a link to Mr. Yeo's article below. I understand that your post didn't mention anything about pain or discomfort, but these changes have worked for me. Best of luck in your search!

http://www.yeodoug.com/resources/faq/fa ... nsion.html