Adding a second counterweight
- MagnumH
- Posts: 207
- Joined: Fri Mar 06, 2020 3:38 pm
- Location: Rochester, NY
Adding a second counterweight
Hi guys!
Has anyone here added an additional counterweight to their horn? I'm finding my newest horn to be on the nose-heavy side and my left hand is feeling the strain across the palm, thumb, and especially the middle finger, after anything more than 45-60 minutes. Possibly I'm just used to lighter equipment - my previous horn was a 2B. I tried it with a rubber plunger balanced behind me and it was instantly better, so we're not talking a lot of weight required.
Rather than the hassle of replacing the handslide with something lightweight, I was wondering about adding a second counterweight behind me, ideally on the brace below the tuning slide (it's a BAC, so the brace on the tuning slide is the curly counterweight - not much room to mod).
Hickey's have a generic counterweight for a decent price - just looking for some input before I plunge in and try it!
Has anyone here added an additional counterweight to their horn? I'm finding my newest horn to be on the nose-heavy side and my left hand is feeling the strain across the palm, thumb, and especially the middle finger, after anything more than 45-60 minutes. Possibly I'm just used to lighter equipment - my previous horn was a 2B. I tried it with a rubber plunger balanced behind me and it was instantly better, so we're not talking a lot of weight required.
Rather than the hassle of replacing the handslide with something lightweight, I was wondering about adding a second counterweight behind me, ideally on the brace below the tuning slide (it's a BAC, so the brace on the tuning slide is the curly counterweight - not much room to mod).
Hickey's have a generic counterweight for a decent price - just looking for some input before I plunge in and try it!
Matt Hawke
Trombonist/Arranger/Bandleader
White Hot Brass Band // The Sideways // The Brass Machine
Stable: BAC Paseo W6 w/ DE MTN102 B+3; King 3B/F w/ Bach 4C; King 2B w/ King 12C
Trombonist/Arranger/Bandleader
White Hot Brass Band // The Sideways // The Brass Machine
Stable: BAC Paseo W6 w/ DE MTN102 B+3; King 3B/F w/ Bach 4C; King 2B w/ King 12C
- BrianAn
- Posts: 65
- Joined: Wed Apr 15, 2020 10:43 am
- Location: Ottawa and Waterloo, Ontario, Canada
Re: Adding a second counterweight
I came across this video on YouTube of a trombonist performing as a guest / featured artist with another band. You can see he has two counterweights on his horn. I think he might be like one of those New Orleans guys on a straight bass trombone, so he might be doing it to balance out where there would normally be valves. Although I guess his situation isn't exactly the same as yours if he's playing a straight bass and you're on a peashooter, but nonetheless it's an example of someone using two counterweights.
You might also be interested in some sort of hand support, like the NeoTech. I use one on my small bore and it works great.
An pronounced "On"
Trombonist in Ottawa and Waterloo
My website: https://briananmusic.com/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/briananmusic/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/brian.an.0/
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@BrianAnMusic
Trombonist in Ottawa and Waterloo
My website: https://briananmusic.com/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/briananmusic/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/brian.an.0/
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@BrianAnMusic
- Burgerbob
- Posts: 5162
- Joined: Mon Apr 23, 2018 8:10 pm
- Location: LA
- Contact:
Re: Adding a second counterweight
What's the new horn?
I find that another counterweight can work, but usually it just makes the horn heavy and not fun.
I find that another counterweight can work, but usually it just makes the horn heavy and not fun.
Aidan Ritchie, LA area player and teacher
-
- Posts: 1323
- Joined: Wed Sep 05, 2018 10:18 pm
Re: Adding a second counterweight
I've used a second counterweight on my newer 8H to give it more resistance and focus (and it worked), but i also play bassbone so i wasn't bothered by the added weight.
That's all i have to say about that.
That's all i have to say about that.
6H (K series)
Elkhart 60s' 6H bell/5H slide
78H (K series)
8H (N series bell w/ modern slide)
88HN
71H (dependant valves)
72H bell section (half moon)
35H alto (K series)
Boneyard custom .509 tenor
Elkhart 60s' 6H bell/5H slide
78H (K series)
8H (N series bell w/ modern slide)
88HN
71H (dependant valves)
72H bell section (half moon)
35H alto (K series)
Boneyard custom .509 tenor
- MagnumH
- Posts: 207
- Joined: Fri Mar 06, 2020 3:38 pm
- Location: Rochester, NY
Re: Adding a second counterweight
It’s the BAC Paseo W6. I‘m more concerned about balance than overall weight, but I was also worried if it would mess up any resonances or anything like that...I figured there was probably a reason it isn’t normally done.
Thanks Thrawn! So you used it intentionally for changing the sound, and it had a noticeable effect? Did you place it on the brace below the tuning slide?
Also, thank you for not BAC-bashing, I know that isn’t easy for ya.
Matt Hawke
Trombonist/Arranger/Bandleader
White Hot Brass Band // The Sideways // The Brass Machine
Stable: BAC Paseo W6 w/ DE MTN102 B+3; King 3B/F w/ Bach 4C; King 2B w/ King 12C
Trombonist/Arranger/Bandleader
White Hot Brass Band // The Sideways // The Brass Machine
Stable: BAC Paseo W6 w/ DE MTN102 B+3; King 3B/F w/ Bach 4C; King 2B w/ King 12C
-
- Posts: 741
- Joined: Thu May 10, 2018 4:24 pm
- Location: Chicago, IL
- Contact:
Re: Adding a second counterweight
Have you tried reaching out to Mike at BAC? He might have an idea for you.
King 2b+
King 3b
King 3b(f)
Conn 79h
Kanstul 1585
Olds O-21 Marching Trombone (Flugabone)
King 3b
King 3b(f)
Conn 79h
Kanstul 1585
Olds O-21 Marching Trombone (Flugabone)
- harrisonreed
- Posts: 5258
- Joined: Fri Aug 17, 2018 12:18 pm
- Location: Fort Riley, Kansas
- Contact:
Re: Adding a second counterweight
It will 100% change the way the horn plays. Could be for the better though
-
- Posts: 1323
- Joined: Wed Sep 05, 2018 10:18 pm
Re: Adding a second counterweight
Thanks Thrawn! So you used it intentionally for changing the sound, and it had a noticeable effect? Did you place it on the brace below the tuning slide?
Also, thank you for not BAC-bashing, I know that isn’t easy for ya.
[/quote]
Yes. To go further into it. I had this paticular 8H made convertible so i could use a CL valve section with the bell. When i would go to the straight neck pipe the sound didn't seem as focused as it was with the valve section. So i put an extra weight on it and it helped it sound like if the valve were on it.
Also, thank you for not BAC-bashing, I know that isn’t easy for ya.
[/quote]
Yes. To go further into it. I had this paticular 8H made convertible so i could use a CL valve section with the bell. When i would go to the straight neck pipe the sound didn't seem as focused as it was with the valve section. So i put an extra weight on it and it helped it sound like if the valve were on it.
6H (K series)
Elkhart 60s' 6H bell/5H slide
78H (K series)
8H (N series bell w/ modern slide)
88HN
71H (dependant valves)
72H bell section (half moon)
35H alto (K series)
Boneyard custom .509 tenor
Elkhart 60s' 6H bell/5H slide
78H (K series)
8H (N series bell w/ modern slide)
88HN
71H (dependant valves)
72H bell section (half moon)
35H alto (K series)
Boneyard custom .509 tenor
-
- Posts: 1051
- Joined: Tue May 08, 2018 2:05 am
- Location: Los Angeles, California
Re: Adding a second counterweight
When I play a horn that has a 2nd counterweight on it, besides looking silly, it usually blows like there is a second counterweight on it. That's usually not a good thing.harrisonreed wrote: ↑Tue Jun 09, 2020 8:57 pm It will 100% change the way the horn plays. Could be for the better though
Oddly enough every now and then it does improve a horn. The 8h Thrawn has does play pretty well with the second counterweight. But... if I added a second counterweight to my straight 42 it would totally kill the resonance of the horn.
Rath R1, Elliott XT
Rath R3, Elliott XT
Rath R4, Elliott XT
Rath R9, Elliott LB
Minick Bass Trombone, Elliott LB
Rath R3, Elliott XT
Rath R4, Elliott XT
Rath R9, Elliott LB
Minick Bass Trombone, Elliott LB
- harrisonreed
- Posts: 5258
- Joined: Fri Aug 17, 2018 12:18 pm
- Location: Fort Riley, Kansas
- Contact:
Re: Adding a second counterweight
I agree, except that the BAC doesn't have a counterweight. It'd be a first counterweight. That pigtail nonsense is not a counterweight, hence the unbalanced horn.
At the risk of derailing, I'll say that BAC often prioritizes form over function.
At the risk of derailing, I'll say that BAC often prioritizes form over function.
- AuntieAmanda
- Posts: 13
- Joined: Tue Dec 04, 2018 4:47 pm
Re: Adding a second counterweight
Apologies if this is an obvious suggestion, but...
Perhaps you could replace the existing counterweight with a heavier one, rather than having two counterweights?
And if you want to know what effect adding or taking away stuff will have on your trombone, try it.
Perhaps you could replace the existing counterweight with a heavier one, rather than having two counterweights?
And if you want to know what effect adding or taking away stuff will have on your trombone, try it.
- DougHulme
- Posts: 499
- Joined: Fri Apr 27, 2018 12:54 am
- Location: Portsmouth UK
- Contact:
Re: Adding a second counterweight
One of the guys that plays tenor in one of my bands has an extra weight on his 3B. He's a decent player and intelligent so I think you can say there is something in it (for him at least) he has identical weights on both the cross braces. The fact that he has the second weight on the lower brace suggests to me its probably as much about sound as balnce. Personal preference and what suits you but I am sure it will alter the way the horn plays either for better or worse. None of which helps if there isnt somewhere to attach the weight on a BAC horn. How about the Minick trick of filling the tubing with lead, though that would have to go back to Mike or another tech to achieve and probably relacquer. AuntieAmanda has probably just posted the most obvious answer except there isnt a counter balance to start with and nowhere to attach one (easily) ... Doug
- MagnumH
- Posts: 207
- Joined: Fri Mar 06, 2020 3:38 pm
- Location: Rochester, NY
Re: Adding a second counterweight
Thanks all! I’ve emailed BAC to see if they have any suggestions, and if that falls short then I’ll try the generic weight from Hickey’s on the brace below the tuning slide.
I did think about replacing/filling the original loop weight but I’d rather not go to that level of modding or replacing the tuning slide.
I did think about replacing/filling the original loop weight but I’d rather not go to that level of modding or replacing the tuning slide.
I always wondered if the loop weighed less than a normal weight... I confess I really like the aesthetics of it though!harrisonreed wrote: ↑Wed Jun 10, 2020 12:59 am I agree, except that the BAC doesn't have a counterweight. It'd be a first counterweight. That pigtail nonsense is not a counterweight, hence the unbalanced horn.
Matt Hawke
Trombonist/Arranger/Bandleader
White Hot Brass Band // The Sideways // The Brass Machine
Stable: BAC Paseo W6 w/ DE MTN102 B+3; King 3B/F w/ Bach 4C; King 2B w/ King 12C
Trombonist/Arranger/Bandleader
White Hot Brass Band // The Sideways // The Brass Machine
Stable: BAC Paseo W6 w/ DE MTN102 B+3; King 3B/F w/ Bach 4C; King 2B w/ King 12C
-
- Posts: 1323
- Joined: Wed Sep 05, 2018 10:18 pm
Re: Adding a second counterweight
harrisonreed wrote: ↑Wed Jun 10, 2020 12:59 am I agree, except that the BAC doesn't have a counterweight. It'd be a first counterweight. That pigtail nonsense is not a counterweight, hence the unbalanced horn.
At the risk of derailing, I'll say that BAC often prioritizes form over function.
6H (K series)
Elkhart 60s' 6H bell/5H slide
78H (K series)
8H (N series bell w/ modern slide)
88HN
71H (dependant valves)
72H bell section (half moon)
35H alto (K series)
Boneyard custom .509 tenor
Elkhart 60s' 6H bell/5H slide
78H (K series)
8H (N series bell w/ modern slide)
88HN
71H (dependant valves)
72H bell section (half moon)
35H alto (K series)
Boneyard custom .509 tenor
-
- Posts: 1323
- Joined: Wed Sep 05, 2018 10:18 pm
Re: Adding a second counterweight
Funny enough, i took the second weight off recently since i have two other 8Hs (a 58' and 68') and i want to play those more (theres a long story about my newer 8H). The other two i felt didn't need the second weight because i have an older Conn weight (marching men) on the 58' and those weights are heavier than the new weights, and the 68' bell feels a bit heavier than a normal Elkhart bell.mrdeacon wrote: ↑Wed Jun 10, 2020 12:52 amWhen I play a horn that has a 2nd counterweight on it, besides looking silly, it usually blows like there is a second counterweight on it. That's usually not a good thing.harrisonreed wrote: ↑Tue Jun 09, 2020 8:57 pm It will 100% change the way the horn plays. Could be for the better though
Oddly enough every now and then it does improve a horn. The 8h Thrawn has does play pretty well with the second counterweight. But... if I added a second counterweight to my straight 42 it would totally kill the resonance of the horn.
Maybe when you talk with bac Magnum you should suggest a modular weight system or a heavier pigtail.
6H (K series)
Elkhart 60s' 6H bell/5H slide
78H (K series)
8H (N series bell w/ modern slide)
88HN
71H (dependant valves)
72H bell section (half moon)
35H alto (K series)
Boneyard custom .509 tenor
Elkhart 60s' 6H bell/5H slide
78H (K series)
8H (N series bell w/ modern slide)
88HN
71H (dependant valves)
72H bell section (half moon)
35H alto (K series)
Boneyard custom .509 tenor
- Oslide
- Posts: 178
- Joined: Tue Apr 03, 2018 9:13 am
- Location: Switzerland, BL
Re: Adding a second counterweight
There was a thread on Trombone Forum about "playing w/out a counterweight on a 6H?"
https://trombonechat.com/viewtopic.php? ... ght#p13681
that gives some opinions (27 posts) as to the effects of more or less weight.
Ray Conniff had two counterweights on his King (3B?) for some time - for whatever reason.
https://trombonechat.com/viewtopic.php? ... ght#p13681
that gives some opinions (27 posts) as to the effects of more or less weight.
Ray Conniff had two counterweights on his King (3B?) for some time - for whatever reason.
Ceterum censeo to fetch All of TTF
- harrisonreed
- Posts: 5258
- Joined: Fri Aug 17, 2018 12:18 pm
- Location: Fort Riley, Kansas
- Contact:
Re: Adding a second counterweight
The Elliott Mason model from BAC has a tweakable counterweight. Kind of like the Edwards Harmonic Brace, but even more like the way Rath's works. That one actually is a counterweight, and the prototype of that horn, at least, could REALLY play. But in this case, like the Edwards version, it's not all or nothing, and the options do more than just change the weight of the horn.
-
- Posts: 1059
- Joined: Fri Mar 23, 2018 11:33 pm
Re: Adding a second counterweight
It may be that you cannot put the weight where you want it. Because the place may be off the horn. Take a look at archers and their weights on rods. The whole point is balance. It may be you're thinking about a weight for balance reasons, but you may need a rod to get to the right location.
- BGuttman
- Posts: 6393
- Joined: Thu Mar 22, 2018 7:19 am
- Location: Cow Hampshire
Re: Adding a second counterweight
For that matter, you may want to look at the contraption Heinz Gries put on his trombone. It's his avatar.baileyman wrote: ↑Wed Jun 10, 2020 8:28 pm It may be that you cannot put the weight where you want it. Because the place may be off the horn. Take a look at archers and their weights on rods. The whole point is balance. It may be you're thinking about a weight for balance reasons, but you may need a rod to get to the right location.
Bruce Guttman
Merrimack Valley Philharmonic Orchestra
"Almost Professional"
Merrimack Valley Philharmonic Orchestra
"Almost Professional"
- heinzgries
- Posts: 236
- Joined: Tue Apr 24, 2018 4:52 pm
- Location: Heidelberg/germany
-
- Posts: 1059
- Joined: Fri Mar 23, 2018 11:33 pm
Re: Adding a second counterweight
Nice job! Now, if you give the rod a right angle to put the weight behind your head it will also counter balance the bell rotation. People with big basses complain about that rotation force on their wrists. I wonder wonder which feels better, a heavy unbalanced bass or an even heavier balanced bass?
-
- Posts: 658
- Joined: Fri Mar 23, 2018 5:47 am
- Location: Oklahoma City
Re: Adding a second counterweight
Is that a second connection point on the bell flare? If so, why?
--Andy in OKC
- MagnumH
- Posts: 207
- Joined: Fri Mar 06, 2020 3:38 pm
- Location: Rochester, NY
Re: Adding a second counterweight
Looks wonderful! Sadly I don't have anything like that kind of technical skill...
Matt Hawke
Trombonist/Arranger/Bandleader
White Hot Brass Band // The Sideways // The Brass Machine
Stable: BAC Paseo W6 w/ DE MTN102 B+3; King 3B/F w/ Bach 4C; King 2B w/ King 12C
Trombonist/Arranger/Bandleader
White Hot Brass Band // The Sideways // The Brass Machine
Stable: BAC Paseo W6 w/ DE MTN102 B+3; King 3B/F w/ Bach 4C; King 2B w/ King 12C
- PSJ
- Posts: 27
- Joined: Thu Mar 29, 2018 8:45 am
- Location: NW Arkansas
Re: Adding a second counterweight
I am going to throw out this maybe stupid idea. Could you try some tape on wheel balancing weights to temporarily see if the added weight will work? You could also get differing weights so you might know how heavy you would need and maybe where to place the counterbalance. Should be able to get some at a tire store.
Just a thought....
Just a thought....
Paul
Custom Getzen Custom 3062AF - Schilke Bill Reichenbach
And many, many others..........
Custom Getzen Custom 3062AF - Schilke Bill Reichenbach
And many, many others..........
- BGuttman
- Posts: 6393
- Joined: Thu Mar 22, 2018 7:19 am
- Location: Cow Hampshire
Re: Adding a second counterweight
I do the same thing with a D battery. It's about the same weight as a normal counterweight.PSJ wrote: ↑Thu Jun 11, 2020 10:27 am I am going to throw out this maybe stupid idea. Could you try some tape on wheel balancing weights to temporarily see if the added weight will work? You could also get differing weights so you might know how heavy you would need and maybe where to place the counterbalance. Should be able to get some at a tire store.
Just a thought....
Bruce Guttman
Merrimack Valley Philharmonic Orchestra
"Almost Professional"
Merrimack Valley Philharmonic Orchestra
"Almost Professional"
- MagnumH
- Posts: 207
- Joined: Fri Mar 06, 2020 3:38 pm
- Location: Rochester, NY
Re: Adding a second counterweight
I thought about that. Don't want to tarnish the horn, but if I use electric tape and don't leave it too long that should be grand, I'd think. Good ideas!BGuttman wrote: ↑Thu Jun 11, 2020 12:58 pmI do the same thing with a D battery. It's about the same weight as a normal counterweight.PSJ wrote: ↑Thu Jun 11, 2020 10:27 am I am going to throw out this maybe stupid idea. Could you try some tape on wheel balancing weights to temporarily see if the added weight will work? You could also get differing weights so you might know how heavy you would need and maybe where to place the counterbalance. Should be able to get some at a tire store.
Just a thought....
Matt Hawke
Trombonist/Arranger/Bandleader
White Hot Brass Band // The Sideways // The Brass Machine
Stable: BAC Paseo W6 w/ DE MTN102 B+3; King 3B/F w/ Bach 4C; King 2B w/ King 12C
Trombonist/Arranger/Bandleader
White Hot Brass Band // The Sideways // The Brass Machine
Stable: BAC Paseo W6 w/ DE MTN102 B+3; King 3B/F w/ Bach 4C; King 2B w/ King 12C
- heinzgries
- Posts: 236
- Joined: Tue Apr 24, 2018 4:52 pm
- Location: Heidelberg/germany
-
- Posts: 658
- Joined: Fri Mar 23, 2018 5:47 am
- Location: Oklahoma City
Re: Adding a second counterweight
Thx. By the way, I really like the idea of being able to control the balance in two directions.heinzgries wrote: ↑Thu Jun 11, 2020 2:56 pmits from the first try, but it was the wrong place to fix the counterweight.
I forgot to remove it before i made the picture.
-Andy in OKC
- dukesboneman
- Posts: 738
- Joined: Mon Apr 02, 2018 4:40 pm
- Location: Sarasota, Florida
- Contact:
Re: Adding a second counterweight
I play a Weril TIS Alto trombone and it`s really front heavy . I added an old King counter weight and BINGO all problems went away.
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.